When Steel Talks
Everything Related to the Steelpan Instrument and Music
Trinidad All Stars steel orchestra. Large Band category. Arranged by Leon "Smooth" Edwards. Performed at the Queens Park Savannah, Trinidad & T...
Join When Steel Talks
In the eyes of the judges and the people, the best band won panorama. One should not criticize that, unless you are prejudice and seeking to advance your personal opinion. Leon Edwards is not underrated, he is exceptional and under appreciated, like Thelonius Monk was for a long time. He has followed a rich tradition created by Mr. Neville Jules, we need to embrace and recognize their genius.
It was a great night of competition. Hugely enjoyable! The one sure winner was Pan, and Panorama.
Without the competition aspect, something would be missing ...
But equally, once the results are in, the judgment of the judges is final. Win or lose, no one should lose any sleep over it. Come stronger and harder next year, when ... may the best band win!
- Big Sid
Phase II was my pick for the winning band ... no offence to All Stars or the judges, this was a very competitive Panorama.
Smooth's arrangement was light and airy, with a 3-note riff as the centre-piece that led off in different directions, kind of like a centre-forward dribbling down the football field.
Boogsie had a much harder job, working with 4- 6- and 8-note melodic elements, seeking to find a way forward, checker-board style, for a whole attack, to continue the football metaphor.
Boogsie gave us a fuller meal, IMHO.
My placings would have been as follows:
1. Phase II
4. All Stars
5. Silver Stars
8. Redemption Sound
10. Angel Harps
Relative to the judges, I am promoting Renegades two places to 2nd, and I'm promoting Invaders four places to 3rd place. I'm demoting All Stars and Silver Stars, but that's just my subjective opinion.
From another angle, I am agreeing with the judges as to the bottom four placements, and the top seven. So I wouldn't object to a 7-way tie for 1st, and a 4-way tie for 2nd place, LOL!!!
I'm glad to see Harmonites back firing on all cylinders. One of my enduring memories of carnival is jumping up with Harmonites that year they won Panorama back in '68 or '69, and going off into a bliss state.
Any of these bands, plus another dozen in the medium category, could represent this country with distinction, anywhere in the world. My hat's off to all of them.
Congratulations especially to Smooth and All Stars!
Play Your Self 2012 Panorama Champs CONGRATS
oh gooorm I enjoyed this!!!!! .....THAT is great pan. CONGRATS! It was sweet, joyful and classy!
The All Stars is the best, what a performance.
An All Stars fan forever.
What a performance! What a first class arrangment! Smooth is a genius! I wish I could have been there to see and hear live. I probably would have misbehaved! What I can I say......I am an All Stars super fan
Very Good Performance Keep up the Good Works
Welcome toWhen Steel Talks
Sign Upor Sign In
Or sign in with:
© 2020 Created by When Steel Talks.
Report an Issue |
Terms of Service
Please check your browser settings or contact your system administrator.