Phase II won its first North Panorama title in 1977 playing "I Like To Beat Pan" before winning the National Panorama Competition in 1987 playing "Feeling Nice". They have also produced other legendary favorites like "I Music", "Musical Wine", "Fire Down Below", and "Birthday Party". They have come close to winning Panorama so many times that some players within the band comically suggest that they be given a plaque commemorating the most second place finishes in the history of Panorama.
This article covers BOOGSIE and PHASE II through 2005.
After seeing what little acclaim BOOGSIE SHARPE was given in a recent WST discussion on "ARRANGERS IMPACTING PANORAMA" I decided to bring "THE BOOGSIE SHARPE STORY" to the forum.
Replies
Oh Morning Glory...don't be so thin-skinned meh brother....there is no arranger who has never been criticized...Maitland gave "his opinion"...there is nothing to defend there...
Morning Glory…..I think the problem here is you are attached to Boogsie and as such will defend him.
I on the other hand have no relations to anyone. I know a lot of arrangers and I have spoken to them at length, however I will be the first to tell them they are full of it or that tune sounds like crap.
Boogsie is a legend I don’t doubt that, but that doesn’t mean he has nothing more to learn.
For someone who cannot read music and plays by ear I think it’s extraordinary.
I will be the first to criticize someone who I think dropped the ball. For example in 2016 Zander arranged what I would call a masterpiece for Desperadoes, however this year he lost his way and veered off the melody into no-man’s land, still a good rendition but not what the adjudicators expected from an accomplished arranger. If I was a hater Boogsie would be nowhere on my list of best panorama tunes.
An arranger can do his part and create the best arrangement ever, but it comes down to the drill master and the band to execute the arrangers vision. That is sometimes very hard to achieve. In 2016 with Desperadoes playing the slow version of A Different Me… You could hear every single instrument and you knew the vision of Zander.
Here is my list again….As you can see Boogsie features prominently on the list.
Panorama Best
1. Trinidad All Stars - Woman On The Bass Leon Smooth Edwards
2. Renegades - 'Mystery Band' Jitt Samaroo
3. Trinidad All stars "The Hammer" Leon Smooth Edwards
4. Trinidad All Stars - Unknown Band (1981) Leon Smooth Edwards
5. Trinidad All Stars - Curry Tabanca Leon Smooth Edwards
6. Fonclaire 1990 Pan By Storm Ken Professor Philmore
7. Desperadoes Steel Orchestra "Fire Coming Down" Robbie Greenidge
8. Trinidad All Stars "Doh Back Back" Leon Smooth Edwards
9. Phase II - Woman Is Boss Len Boogsie Sharp
10. Renegades - Guitar Pan Jitt Samaroo
11. Trinidad All Stars - "Dus In Deh Face" Eddie Quarless
12. Phase II Pan Groove - Pan Rising Len Boogsie Sharp
13. Renegades - 'The Bees Melody' Jitt Samaroo
14. Phase II Pan Groove "This Feeling Nice" Len Boogsie Sharp
15. Despers – Rebecca Clive Bradley
16. Phase II Pan Groove "I Music" Len Boogsie Sharp
17. Desperadoes Steel Orchestra - 'Different Me" Carlton Zander Alexander
18. Desperadoes – Party Clive Bradley
19. Trinidad All Stars - Full Extreme Leon Smooth Edwards
20. Fonclaire - Len"Boogsie" Sharpe's "Fire Down Below" Ken Professor Philmore
21. Hatters - Tribute to Spree Simon Steve Achaiba (Only South band to ever win panorama as a big band)
22. Skiffle Bunch - Coffee Street (Honorable mention) Andy Narell
23. Trinidad All Stars – Showtime Leon Smooth Edwards (Playing from position #1 in the finals)
Ey ey you Maitland....yuh leave out Bradley's two masterpieces..."Pan in Harmony" (1976) and I"n My House" (2009)....But then again.....those are "your" choices...good selections too...
Morning Glory: That is a false attack on MARTIN MAITLAND!!! Because he is one of the most SENSIBLE (and INFORMED) posters on this forum.